Healthy Living Practices for Writers – Silent Killer: Imposter Syndrome
By Mary Lynn Cloghesy and Jason Schembri
Did you know that you have a silent killer within you? One that is capable of not only derailing your writing life, but also your profession, personal relationships, and pastimes? Recent research has shown that creatives are uniquely susceptible to this disease due to the subjective nature of their work, the solitary aspects of their craft, and the competitive landscape of the arts. A whopping 70% of writers will suffer from this affliction, including some unlikely characters. Consider what Dr. Maya Angelou has said about herself and her work, “I have written eleven books, but each time I think, ‘Uh oh, they’re going to find out now. I’ve run a game on everybody, and they’re going to find me out.’” She’s not the only one. Even John Steinbeck has cried, “I am not a writer. I’ve been fooling myself and other people.” If the icons among us are negatively impacted by Imposter Syndrome, then what hope is there for the rest of us? Clearly, it’s critical to know what it is and how to deal with it in order to protect ourselves from this author interrupter.
What is Imposter Syndrome?
While you may not know the term, I’m guessing you’re familiar with its symptoms. Ask yourself: Have I experienced persistent self-doubt or feelings of inadequacy despite evidence of success? Have I wondered if I was a fraud or feared being exposed as such regardless of my skills, qualifications or achievements? If so, you’re in the thralls of Imposter Syndrome. It’s a form of dysfunctional thinking that has been described as “chronic self-doubt and a sense of intellectual fraudulence that overrides any feelings of success or external proof of competence.” This mental affliction plays on your fears, needling you with subliminal suggestions, and causes you to question yourself, your talent, and your ability to achieve your dreams. It’s subtle, insidious, and stalking you right now. In fact, it’s such a common experience among writers that it could be considered an epidemic.
While Imposter Syndrome will cause you to hang your head in shame, it has many other faces. It will drive you to adopt the behaviours listed below rather than address its root causes, especially when you are feeling vulnerable, such as during the query process or in the midst of critiques. Here are the masks it wears:
Perfectionism – Setting impossibly high standards and feeling like a failure when they aren’t met.
Overworking – Trying to compensate for perceived inadequacies by working excessively.
Discounting success – Attributing achievements to luck or external factors rather than talent, skill or effort.
Fear of failure – Avoiding new challenges due to the fear of being "found out.”
Diagnosing Imposter Syndrome
To combat this disease, you must diagnose it correctly, but how do you know if you’re simply having a bad day or struggling with Imposter Syndrome? Frequency and consistency are important factors to consider, as are patterns in your thinking that reveal deep-seated worry and self-sabotage. Telltale signs that you are suffering from Imposter Syndrome include the following:
Negative Self-Talk
Do you often think, "I’m not a real writer," even though you’re increasing your word count regularly and actively creating new works?
Do you believe your work isn’t good enough, no matter how much you revise?
Perfectionism & Procrastination
Do you keep rewriting the same passages because they’re "never good enough"?
Do you delay submitting work or starting a project because you fear failure?
Dismissing Accomplishments
Do you downplay praise or attribute success to luck instead of your talent and hard work?
Even after recognition (awards, nominations, publication), do you feel like you don’t deserve it?
Fear of Being "Exposed"
Do you worry that other writers, editors, or readers will figure out you’re a fraud?
Does the idea of publishing or speaking about your work make you anxious?
Comparing Yourself to Others
Do you feel like other authors are "real writers," but you’re just faking it?
Do you look at their success and think, "I’ll never be as good as them"?
Overworking to Prove Yourself
Do you push yourself to exhaustion, believing you must work twice as hard to deserve success?
Do you avoid celebrating milestones because you can’t accept you’ve really earned them yet?
What can you do about it?
Recognizing Imposter Syndrome is the first step. Take off the mask, look in the mirror, and say out loud, “I am a writer. I am accomplished, I work hard, and I deserve my success,” then notice how you feel. Free write about it. The key is to manage self-doubt rather than attempt to eliminate it. Leading expert, Dr. Valerie Young, author of The Secret Thoughts of Successful Women, has stated, “The only difference between people who feel like impostors and those who don’t is that the impostors’ thoughts stop them.” Here are some practical steps:
Acknowledge It & Call It Out
When you hear that inner voice saying, "I’m not a real writer," or "I don’t deserve this," challenge it. Ask yourself: What evidence do I have that this is true? Spoiler: There isn’t any. Use the mirror to reflect what is real instead. Write an affirmation and say it out loud to yourself, then get back to your writing. Your work and readers are waiting.
Reframe Your Thinking
Pay attention to your inner dialogue. Instead of saying, "I just got lucky" try: "I worked hard, improved my craft, and took advantage of my opportunities." Whenever doubts and fears come up, remind yourself, "Every writer doubts themselves—this is normal, but it doesn’t define me."
Keep a “Proof” Folder
Create a digital or physical folder where you save:
✅ Positive feedback from editors, agents, or readers
✅ Good reviews or contest recognitions
✅ Personal milestones—finishing a draft, hitting a word count goal, getting shortlisted
On tough days, revisit these to remind yourself that your work has real value and made a positive impact.Stop the Comparison Game
It’s easy to look at other writers and feel lost or behind, but their journey isn’t yours. Even bestselling authors struggle with Imposter Syndrome! Instead of comparing yourself to others, focus on your progress. The only person to compare yourself to is you. Also, cheer others on knowing they need your support as much as you need theirs.
Write Through It
Fear and self-doubt thrive in inaction. Keep writing, even if you don’t feel "good enough" that day. One of the best ways to grow as a writer is to write. The only way out is through.
Share Your Struggles with Fellow Writers
Imposter Syndrome relies on silence. Talking about it with other writers can be eye-opening—they probably feel the same way! Other authors will have tips as to how to beat this too, so reach out to your critique group or friends in the field to gather collective wisdom.
Celebrate Your Wins (Big & Small)
Finished a chapter? Got positive feedback? Submitted to an agent? Celebrate it! Recognizing progress helps rewire your brain to see your success instead of dismissing it. If in doubt, go for a quick win: write a flash fiction piece, watch a video on the art and craft of writing, read one of your favorite authors. Your choices are endless.
Accept That Doubt is Normal
Even established authors battle Imposter Syndrome. The trick is to acknowledge the fear but not let it control you. You’re not an imposter—you’re just a writer pushing past your perceived limits.
Healthy Living Top Tip
Like most diseases, it’s a coordinated approach over time that promotes healing. While there are some actionable steps included in this article to help you diagnose and manage Imposter Syndrome, you may need to go deeper. Our top tip for this month is to be curious about what’s happening, especially if you are struggling, and to acknowledge that you are not alone.
Don’t allow your internal worries to cross over into reality and kill your success. Save that for your writing. One thing that is unique to writers is we get to breathe life into “real” imposters (excuse the oxymoron), villains and victims, then wipe them out with the keyboard. Take advantage of this unique ability and feel emboldened to vanquish your internal imposter. Eradicate the disease at its source. Your story awaits.
Authors: Mary Lynn Cloghesy & Jason Schembri. Mary Lynn is the founder of the Leadership Literary Lab (https://leadershipliterarylab.com), and Jason is a long-term weight loss specialist (https://jasonschembri.coach) Together, they host a luxury writing retreat in the Canadian Rockies.
